AVAC v. United States Department of State

Where things stand

Last updated November 6, 2026

The case is still open. In September 2026, the judge overseeing AVAC’s lawsuit and a related case brought by Global Health Council ruled that foreign aid money Congress approved, but the government never spent, won’t expire while the court reviews what happened. For now, that money is still available.

Global Health Council has asked the judge to order the government to spend those funds as Congress intended. The judge hasn’t ruled yet.

At stake is more than HIV funding: it’s whether Congress, not the President, decides how federal money is spent.

Background

On its first day in office, the current US administration issued a sweeping foreign aid freeze. The decision halted life-saving global health and HIV programs, cut off active grants, and stopped research and programs in mid-stream. The consequences were severe, costing millions of lives and livelihoods around the world.

AVAC and the Journalism Development Network responded by suing the President, the State Department, the US Agency for International Development (USAID), and others, seeking emergency relief. Global Health Council led a parallel lawsuit at the same time. Together, the cases argued that the freeze was unlawful and harmful. It bypassed Congress’s authority over federal spending, jeopardized health as a human right, and undermined global trust in US leadership.

Ultimately, the lawsuits unlocked the payment of millions of dollars of development assistance for work that was done in January and February 2025, but millions more dollars were lost. AVAC’s case remains active in 2026, but lawsuits will never bring back everything that was taken away, or undo the long-term damage caused by the sudden dismantling of global health systems.

“It takes time to build up these programs and relationships … it will take more time to re-build, no matter who funds these efforts.”

Mitchell Warren
AVAC Executive Director

This is a defining moment for HIV prevention and global health equity. Stand with us.

Make your contribution today. Donate today to help fund our efforts. Every contribution helps us keep the pressure on!

Key Dates

  1. January 20, 2025

    US Presidential administration issues Executive Order “pausing” foreign aid for 90-day review.

  2. February 10, 2025

    AVAC, Journalism Development Network, and Public Citizen file suit against funding freeze; read about it in our press release, New York Times, Devex, and Politico.

  3. February 13, 2025

    Judge Amir Ali issues temporary restraining order, ordering government to reinstate foreign aid funding; here are the press statements from Public Citizen and the Global Health Council and media reports here: NPR, Time, Devex, and The Guardian.

  4. March 5, 2025

    In response to the government’s request, the Supreme Court ruled that the administration must release up to $2 billion in frozen foreign aid funding. See coverage in ABC News, the BBC, Bloomberg, CNN, Devex, The Guardian, Health Policy Watch, the New York Times, NPR, Reuters, Wall Street Journal and Washington Post.

  5. August 13, 2025

    The US Court of Appeals for the DC Circuit overturned the District Court’s injunction that compelled the restoration of vital foreign aid funding. Read AVAC’s release and Public Citizen’s.

  6. September 26, 2025

    The Supreme Court granted the Administration’s request to stay an injunction that would require the Administration to obligate $4 billion of foreign assistance funds before they expire on September 30 – as required by law. See coverage in Slate and New York Times.

  7. September 2026

    Judge Amir Ali who oversees the GHC and AVAC’s case, suspended the September 30 expiration date for any disputed funds that State or USAID failed to obligate, meaning those funds remain available while the court examines what happened. As AVAC Executive Director Mitchell Warren said this week, “the issue extends beyond foreign assistance or the HIV response; it is fundamentally about Congress’s constitutional power of the purse.”

Learn more about AVAC v State and Global Health Council v Trump. See also Public Citizen’s fact sheet on the case.

Read more about the case