Global philanthropic funding increased by 4.1 percent from 2016 levels and amounted to US$164 million, or 14.6 percent of overall funding. The Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation (BMGF) remained the largest funder and increased its contribution by 6.6 percent, to US$150.2 million. Wellcome Trust investment fell for the fifth consecutive year to an annual US$2 million.
The full report, HIV Prevention Research & Development Investments 2017: Investing to end the epidemic, is available for download.
Press Release
AVAC: Kay Marshall, kay@avac.org, +1-347-249-6375
IAVI: Anita Kawatra, akawatra@iavi.org, +1 212-847-1055
Madrid – HIV prevention research funding continued to decline in 2017 for the fifth consecutive year, driven largely by a five-year low in US public sector funding, according to a report released today at the HIV Research for Prevention (HIVR4P 2018) conference in Madrid, Spain.
The Resource Tracking for HIV Prevention R&D Working Group’s 14th annual report, Investing to End the Epidemic, documents funding that fell to the lowest level in more than a decade: In 2017, funding for HIV prevention research and development (R&D) decreased by 3.5 percent (US$40 million) from the previous year, falling to US$1.13 billion.
This declining funding comes at a time of great optimism for research, with a slate of efficacy trials across the prevention pipeline – including major HIV vaccine, passive antibody and next generation PrEP efficacy trials – and critical follow-on research for proven antiretroviral-based prevention options, notably the dapivirine vaginal ring. But it also comes a time when the broader HIV field is grappling with a prevention crisis that is exacerbated by decreased funding for the overall HIV response and a lack of political will to adequately fund a response that will ensure the world meets the ambitious prevention targets to end the epidemic.
The Working Group warns that getting to zero new infections will not only require the expansion of existing options like voluntary medical male circumcision (VMMC) and oral pre-exposure prophylaxis (PrEP), but also the development of innovative new products, including long-acting, antiretroviral-based prevention options and a vaccine. Sustained funding is critical to keep the full gamut of HIV prevention research moving forward in a timely manner. Even small declines in funding can delay or sideline promising, new HIV prevention options that are needed to end the HIV epidemic.
“Make no mistake. We are in a prevention crisis and we cannot afford a further funding crisis,” said Mitchell Warren, AVAC executive director. “It is unacceptable that donor funding for HIV prevention research continues to fall year after year even as research is moving new options closer to reality. We need continued and sustained investment to keep HIV prevention research on track to provide the additional tools that are required for sustainable, durable control of the HIV epidemic.”
The US government continued to be the major funder of HIV prevention research, contributing almost three-fourths of overall funding. A decrease of almost six percent, though, brought funding to a five-year low of US$830 million. The Working Group noted that sharp declines in US government funding have a major impact on the biomedical HIV prevention R&D field. With uncertainty around continued political will to fund the HIV response, this trend is extremely worrying.
Together, the US public sector and the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation (BMGF) represented 87 percent of the total global investment in 2017, an imbalance that has continued for several years. The Working Group in this year’s report cautioned against the disproportionate impact of shifting donor priorities by these two donors on cutting-edge research, noting that a US$50 million decrease in vaccine R&D in 2017 was largely attributed to cuts from the US government, while a 67 percent increase in VMMC funding in 2017 is due largely to enhanced investment from BMGF. The Working Group renewed a call to diversify the funding base to ensure both the sustainability of the field and that decades of gains made in scientific innovation are not lost to fluctuating investment.
The Working Group noted with concern that funding by the European Commission (EC) dropped by almost half from 2016 to 2017 (US$14.4 million in 2016 to US$7.6 million). Noting increases in public sector funding from Canada, Brazil and the Netherlands, the Working Group called on other European countries to increase investment in critical HIV prevention tools to help end the epidemic and to offset the drop in EC funding.
“A true end to AIDS will only be possible if we can develop and deploy an effective, accessible HIV vaccine and other biomedical innovations to prevent HIV infection,” said Mark Feinberg, M.D., Ph.D., President and CEO of the International AIDS Vaccine Initiative. “Decades of research are paying off with the most exciting advances we’ve seen to date. But progress can only continue with sustained public and private sector investment in HIV prevention R&D.”
As researchers, implementers, advocates and funders gather this week in Madrid to review progress in HIV prevention research, there is much to be optimistic about in HIV science and in the accumulated knowledge of how to end the epidemic. At the same time, sobering changes in the funding and policy environment could imperil future progress and wipe out the progress made. Funding constraints, policy changes, shifting donor priorities and shifting demographics will all play a role in the world’s ability to respond to the continued challenges that HIV presents.
“With 5000 people becoming infected with HIV every day it is critical that we both scale up the effective HIV prevention programmes we currently have and invest in new technologies and solutions so that they can become a reality for the populations most affected by HIV,” said Tim Martineau, Deputy Executive Director, Programme a.i. UNAIDS. “Doing both will avert new infections, save lives and reduce the rising costs of life-long antiretroviral treatment.”
The report and infographics on prevention research investment are online at www.hivresourcetracking.org and on social media with #HIVPxinvestment.
###
Since 2000, the Resource Tracking for HIV Prevention R&D Working Group (formerly the HIV Vaccines & Microbicides Resource Tracking Working Group) has employed a comprehensive methodology to track trends in research and development (R&D) investments and expenditures for biomedical HIV prevention options. AVAC leads the secretariat of the Working Group, that also includes the International AIDS Vaccine Initiative (IAVI) and the Joint United Nations Programme on HIV/AIDS (UNAIDS). This year’s report is additionally made possible by the support of several donors, including the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation and the American people through the US President’s Emergency Plan for AIDS Relief (PEPFAR) and the US Agency for International Development (USAID). The contents are the responsibility of AVAC and the Working Group and do not necessarily reflect the views of PEPFAR, USAID or the United States Government. AVAC does not accept funding from the pharmaceutical industry.
[UPDATE]: The new report was a feature story by UNAIDS, Global HIV prevention targets at risk.
Today, the Resource Tracking for HIV Prevention R&D Working Group (Working Group) launched its 14th annual report—which details 2017 investments—at the HIV Research for Prevention (HIVR4P) conference in Madrid.
Flat and/or reduced funding for HIV/AIDS and other global health issues threatens to roll back progress worldwide. There is belated and widespread acknowledgment of a prevention crisis that can only be addressed by taking today’s tools to scale while researching new ones. Given this backdrop, the report is a powerful advocacy tool. This year’s report notes troubling trends in investment flows for biomedical HIV prevention at a moment of major promise in the research landscape. The report tracks the origins, trends and direction of global funding as well as the resulting effect(s) on the prevention research funding landscape.
Key Findings
The report shows that funding for HIV prevention research funding declined for the fifth consecutive year—and by 3.5 percent in 2017 to US$1.13 billion—the lowest total observed since 2005. This reduction was unevenly distributed. Investment increased for pre-exposure prophylaxis (PrEP) and voluntary medical male circumcision (VMMC) but decreased for AIDS vaccines, microbicides, prevention of vertical transmission (PMTCT), treatment as prevention (TasP) and female condoms.
The overall decline is driven largely by a reduction in US public-sector funding, with levels dropping by 5.8 percent from 2016 to US$830 million. This is a five-year low in investment. Outside the US public sector, another major decrease came from the European Commission, with funding levels dropping by 47 percent to US$7.6 million in 2017. The impact of these cuts was cushioned by increases from Australia, Brazil, Canada, Japan and the Netherlands. While the number of philanthropic donors decreased from 12 to 10 in 2017, levels of funding grew by 4.1 percent to US$164 million or 14.6 percent of overall funding. This is largely due to the 6.6 percent increase in investment from the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation.
The report notes that the HIV prevention R&D space is at an exciting yet precarious juncture. Ongoing late-stage efficacy trials for preventive AIDS vaccines, long-acting injectable PrEP and antibody-mediated prevention could yield new options in the coming years. Then there’s also the dapivirine vaginal ring that is currently awaiting a regulatory opinion from the European Medical Association. However, the current funding landscape is not set up for sustainability or longevity, which is essential to help ensure that new products move from research and eventually to those who need it. Out of every dollar spent on HIV prevention research, 87 cents are from the two biggest donors, the US public sector and the Gates Foundation—a literal case of having all the coins in one basket. The report advocates for diversifying the funding base and developing long-term funding strategies to support the delivery of innovative prevention tools and a durable end to the epidemic.
The Resource Tracking Working Group hopes these reports will serve as tools for advocacy and be used to inform public policy that supports and helps to accelerate scientific progress. We thank all of the individuals who contributed data to the report and who gave time and effort as trial participants.
Check out the report, share it with your fellow advocates, and be sure to let us know if your organization is a funder or recipient of HIV prevention grants, or if you have further questions!
We are kicking off the launch of the report with a press conference at HIV R4P, which can be viewed live at the conference Facebook page and will be archived on the conference website.
In 2017, reported funding for HIV prevention R&D decreased by 3.5 percent (US$40 million) from the previous year, falling to US$1.13 billion. The full report, HIV Prevention Research & Development Investments 2017: Investing to end the epidemic, is available for download. And all the graphics are available as well.
Today AVAC released No Prevention, No End, our 2018 annual report on the state of the field. Starting from the title—which humbly borrows the cadence of the call for an end to state-sanctioned violence against Black Americans, “No Justice, No Peace”—through to the closing words, “This is the worst possible moment for slowing down,” the Report is a call to action and guide for addressing the HIV prevention crisis that threatens progress in curtailing epidemics worldwide.
Click here to download the Report and individual sections and graphics; click here for a new episode of the Px Pulse podcast which covers the Report’s key themes and features lead author Emily Bass, AVAC’s Director of Strategy and Content.
UNAIDS named the prevention crisis in its July 2018 report, Miles to Go. It acknowledged that the scale-up of antiretroviral treatment, while essential, is insufficient as a prevention strategy. AVAC has been warning of an imbalance in approaches and investments across approaches, and calling for ambitious targets matched with political will, financing, timelines and more since the UNAIDS targets were first launched in 2014. (Check out AVAC Report 2014/5: Prevention on the Line for a summary of this critique of targets.)
In this year’s Report, we call out three core problems with primary prevention and the global HIV response, identifying the risks they bring and the path to a solution. Specifically, we focus on:
AVAC is launching this Report as many stakeholders in HIV prevention research gather in Madrid for the HIV Research for Prevention (R4P) conference. Visit our special R4P page to find us on-site and follow along from afar, to see how the themes of this year’s Report resonate in a global and wide-ranging discussion of HIV prevention research and implementation at a critical time.
Johannesburg’s Bhekisisa Centre for Health Journalism has published this article by Tian Johnson on how South Africa can make smart investments in the female condom. Read on for details on the difference demand creation and counseling can make.
This graphic shows the percentage of total global investment in HIV prevention spent on different interventions in 2015 and 2016. For much more on HIV prevention research & development funding, visit www.hivresourcetracking.org.
It is said success breeds success. 2016 was a year of encouraging progress, indeed success, on a number of HIV prevention fronts. Two trials of the dapivirine vaginal ring showed efficacy, a spate of new vaccine and antibody trials began, and a trial of long-acting injectable PrEP launched.
Those developments are successes by any measure, and yet this year’s funding report from the Resource Tracking for HIV Prevention Research & Development Working Group (Working Group) shows that prevention funding continues to slowly decline overall. Over the same time, cure research got a big bump from global funders. A separate cure-focused brief from the Working Group, developed in partnership with the International AIDS Society (IAS), showed investment in cure research tripled since 2012.
Released today, the Working Group’s latest annual report on global investment in biomedical HIV prevention shows that overall funding for HIV prevention research and development (R&D) has fallen to its lowest level in a decade.
The prevention research report notes that funding for preventive vaccine research constituted the bulk of all investments, followed by investments in cure, microbicides, prevention of mother-to child transmission (PMTCT), PrEP, medical male circumcision (VMMC), treatment as prevention (TasP) and female condoms. Over half of the HIV prevention option tracked by the working group experienced a decline. These trends are somewhat reflective of the cyclical nature of large-scale clinical trials—when trials end, funding drops off. Likewise, as some interventions enter full-scale rollout, like PrEP, VMMC and TasP, research in this area can be expected to slow down. Nevertheless, the overall trends bear close watching and strong advocacy to ensure that research continues. The progress of this research in the context of flat funding should not be misconstrued. Flat funding will not get us where we need to go next.
Taking stock of all that’s been accomplished with a decade of flat funding, it’s important to note that two million people continue to be infected each year. To achieve control of the epidemic, the field must also take stock of what could be achieved with the right priorities.
The right products need to be tested in the populations who need them most, and research does not always connect well to the people who are most at risk. The report explores the demographic breakdown of almost 700,000 participants in ongoing HIV prevention trials in 2016, with the majority of these volunteers residing in sub-Saharan Africa, most notably in treatment as prevention trials in Botswana, Uganda, Kenya and South Africa. Only one in eight trial participants in 2016 belonged to a population most affected by HIV, including MSM and transgender women, injection drug users and cisgender women.
An intensifying trend towards a small number of large investors is concerning. Together, the US public sector and the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation (BMGF) represented 88 percent of the total global investment in 2016, compared to 81 percent in 2015. Simply put, for every dollar spent on HIV prevention R&D in 2016, 88 cents came from just two donors.
On a hopeful note, global investment in research toward an HIV cure increased to US$268 million, a 33 percent increase over 2015 levels, with a number of new funders, and an expanded research portfolio at the US National Institutes of Health. The majority of investments (US$253.2 million) came from the public sector with US$13.8 million invested by philanthropies such as Aids Fonds, amfAR, CANFAR, the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation, Sidaction and Wellcome Trust.
This is a vigorous period in research and development, reflecting a growing recognition from the global community that research has to be part of the long-term fight to end the HIV epidemic. Now is the time to support continued progress with additional, well-targeted resources.
The Resource Tracking Working Group hopes these reports will serve as tools for advocacy and be used to develop public policy that accelerates scientific progress. We thank all of the individuals who contributed data to the report and who gave time and effort as trial participants.
Check out the report, share it with your fellow advocates, and be sure to let us know if your organization is either a funder or recipient of HIV prevention grants or if you have further questions or information about resource tracking at all!
In 2016, funding for HIV prevention R&D decreased by 3 percent (US$35 million) from the previous year, falling to US$1.17 billion. Funding in 2016 signals the lowest annual investment in HIV prevention R&D in more than a decade.
Press Release
AVAC: Kay Marshall, kay@avac.org, +1-347-249-6375
IAVI: Rose Catlos, rcatlos@iavi.org, +1-212-847-1049
New York and Paris —
A new report released today ahead of the 9th IAS Conference on HIV Science documents 2016 funding and highlights a continuing trend of flat or declining funding and its potential impact on further innovation in HIV prevention research and development (R&D).
The Resource Tracking for HIV Prevention R&D Working Group’s (RTWG) 13th annual report, HIV Prevention Research & Development Investments, 2016: Investment priorities to fund innovation in a challenging global health landscape, documents the lowest annual investment in HIV prevention R&D in more than a decade. In 2016, funding for HIV prevention R&D decreased by three percent (US$35 million) from the previous year, falling to US$1.17 billion.
At a time when the field is moving towards a new slate of efficacy trials across the prevention pipeline and follow-on research for successful antiretroviral-based prevention options is underway or planned this trend is worrisome, particularly in light of uncertainties around the sustainability of public sector support from the US and other funders. Even small declines in funding can delay or sideline promising new HIV prevention options that are needed to end the HIV epidemic.
The US continued to be the major funder of HIV prevention research. In fact, 88 cents of every dollar spent on HIV prevention R&D in 2016, came from just two donors: the US public sector and the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation. In contrast, European public sector funding fell by US$10 million from 2015, and at US$59 million, accounted for just six percent of all public sector investment. This is the lowest European funding recorded in the last decade and marks a 52 percent decrease from the peak funding (US$124 million) in 2009. In addition, the number of philanthropic donors fell sharply from a total of 27 in 2015 to just 12 in 2016.
The RTWG renewed a call for a greater range of donors to increase the stability of R&D financing and cushion potential impact if any of the major funders were to reduce their investments. Noting increases in public sector funding from the Netherlands and Sweden, the RTWG called on other European countries to increase investment in critical HIV prevention tools to help end the epidemic.
The past year has seen one new HIV vaccine efficacy trial begin and another planned to begin later in 2017; a novel proof-of-concept trial of antibody-mediated prevention underway; a monthly vaginal ring with the antiretroviral (ARV) drug dapivirine proven effective and under review by the European Medicines Agency; a multipurpose technology combining dapivirine and a contraceptive has launched early-stage trials; a long-acting ARV-based injectable PrEP formulation is beginning efficacy trials; and, finally, daily oral PrEP delivery programs are being scaled up in multiple countries. And behind these more advanced R&D activities come many other different HIV prevention modalities poised to prove themselves in early-stage research.
“The latest figures from UNAIDS show us that there has been progress toward meeting the 90 90 90 treatment goals, but there has been less progress – and less reporting – on meeting the prevention goals that are critical to epidemic control,” said Mitchell Warren, AVAC executive director. “We need to not only vastly accelerate roll out of HIV treatment and existing prevention options, we need continued and sustained investment to keep HIV prevention research on track to provide the new tools that will move the world closer to ending AIDS.”
The RTWG has tracked more than US$17 billion in investment towards biomedical HIV prevention since 2000 and warned that the greatest impact of this investment could be lost without continued and sustained support to move promising prevention options from laboratories and clinics into the lives of those who most need them.
“We are at an incredibly exciting time in the field of HIV prevention research and development with more life saving innovations, science and technology coming to the forefront than ever before,” said Luiz Loures, Deputy Executive Director of UNAIDS. “We cannot allow a lack of funding to set back progress. Invest now and we can end AIDS by 2030.”
The report documents some critical increases in funding, including the highest annual investment in preventive HIV vaccines since 2007, which includes the highest investment by the US public sector in preventive vaccine research since 2000, in part because of the start of the first vaccine efficacy trial in almost a decade. Yet European public sector investment in vaccine research was the lowest since 2001. The increase in support for vaccine research comes at a critical time in vaccine R&D and is an example of funders responding to the need for investment to keep promising research moving forward. The RTWG noted this level of investment should be occurring across the field to support the broadest possible pipeline of promising new HIV prevention options.
“A true end to AIDS will only be possible if we can develop and deploy an effective HIV vaccine and other innovative biomedical products for HIV prevention” said Mark Feinberg, President and CEO of the International AIDS Vaccine Initiative (IAVI). “With growing risk of increasing rates of HIV infection due to demographic trends and incomplete reach of HIV treatment programs, advances being made in HIV R&D needs support and acceleration. Progress can only happen with sustained public and private sector investment in HIV prevention R&D.”
The HIV field comes together in Paris next week at IAS2017 at a time when there is both much to be optimistic about in HIV science and in the accumulated knowledge of what and how we need to deliver treatment, prevention and care to the people who need it most. Yet, as the title of the report notes, this optimism faces a volatile global health landscape. Funding constraints, policy changes, shifting donor priorities and shifting demographics will all play a role in the world’s ability to respond to the continued challenges that HIV presents.
“After years of prudent and increasingly high-impact investment in HIV prevention and treatment, we have seen amazing dividends in lives saved, families kept together, communities revitalized and economies boosted,” added Warren. “We cannot lose that momentum. We have the innovative science. Now we need an expanded cadre of innovative funders who will work with us to ensure a continued return on investment in more lives saved and more infections averted.”
The report and infographics on prevention research investment are online at www.hivresourcetracking.org and on social media with #HIVPxinvestment.
###
Since 2000, the Resource Tracking for HIV Prevention R&D Working Group (formerly the HIV Vaccines & Microbicides Resource Tracking Working Group) has employed a comprehensive methodology to track trends in research and development (R&D) investments and expenditures for biomedical HIV prevention options. AVAC leads the secretariat of the Working Group, that also includes the International AIDS Vaccine Initiative (IAVI) and the Joint United Nations Programme on HIV/AIDS (UNAIDS). This year’s report is additionally made possible by the support of several donors, including the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation and the American people through the US President’s Emergency Plan for AIDS Relief (PEPFAR) and the US Agency for International Development (USAID). The contents are the responsibility of AVAC and the Working Group and do not necessarily reflect the views of PEPFAR, USAID or the United States Government.