Song of the Soul: A VMMC Advocate Puts Her Activism into Poetry at Partners Forum 2015

Khanyisa Dunjwa is a community leader in sexual health and rights in South Africa where she is a member of the SANAC Women’s Sector. As a 2014 AVAC Fellow hosted by NACOSA, Khanyisa paved the way for voluntary medical male circumcision in the Eastern Cape province of South Africa, where traditional male circumcision is part of a widespread initiation rite marking young men’s transition to adulthood.

The poem evokes Khanyisa’s motivation to merge aspects of medical male circumcision with traditional circumcision at a newly established pre-initiation camp in the Eastern Cape. Since implementation of the camps, rates of deaths and other adverse events dropped in the region. A Department of Health report documenting the program and outcomes is pending.

Having concluded a remarkable Fellowship, Khanyisa is pursuing larger scale rollout of the initiation camps and working to support The Eastern Cape Aids Council Civil Society Task Team on Safe Initiation. She also advocates for PrEP and other women’s prevention strategies.

Khanyisa presented this poem along with a poster at the Fellows Wrap-up & Orientation Workshop that took place before and after the AVAC Partner’s Forum in Johannesburg in March.

A voice with no space

my traditional leaders enhance traditional governance
my traditional leaders get support from my government
my community has evolved
i decided to get involved
my community is confronted by a monster
you will get details in my poster
initiation of boys makes us hopeful
sadly when it goes wrong it leaves us shameful
my traditional leaders value traditional circumcision
pity, they don’t see value added of medical male circumcision
wait a minute, my mothers voice is on mute
i need to push
she pushed when she gave birth
i need her voice to prevent death

by Khanyisa Dunjwa

AVAC Report 2014/15: HIV Prevention on the Line

In AVAC Report 2014/15: HIV Prevention on the Line, we take on the current state of global targets for the AIDS response, looking beyond pithy slogans to explore what’s in place and what’s not in terms of targets, resources and action to begin to end the AIDS epidemic. We also provide concise updates and calls to action on key prevention interventions including AIDS vaccines, voluntary medical male circumcision, microbicides, PrEP, and hormonal contraception use and HIV risk.

Intervention Update: Voluntary Medical Male Circumcision

Excerpted from AVAC Report: HIV Prevention on the Line, this update cites the success of a previous VMMC target and suggests the current lack of a target moving forward will stifle continued progress.

Targets that Worked

As seen in this graphic from AVAC Report 2014/15: HIV Prevention on the Line, ambitious coverage targets that are well-defined in terms of the components of service delivery, impact and populations and need led to success for VMMC (VMMC) and antiretroviral therapy (ART).

Past Success, Present Gaps: VMMC targets, 2011 and today

VMMC (VMMC) is a highly effective HIV prevention strategy that has benefited from ambitious target setting that ticked all the boxes—investment, political will and evidence. This graphic is from AVAC Report 2014/15: HIV Prevention on the Line.

AVAC Report: HIV Prevention on the Line

AVAC’s annual report of the field, the upcoming CROI meeting and why the coming year is the best and worst of times for HIV prevention

Next week, scientists, advocates and clinicians will gather in Seattle for the Conference on Retroviruses and Opportunistic Infections (CROI), a venerable HIV meeting that often triggers media coverage of the AIDS epidemic and the potential for curbing it and preserving health in people living with HIV.

A range of data is expected from CROI including “late-breaker” abstracts that will showcase data from IPERGAY and PROUD, two trials of oral PrEP using TDF/FTC in gay men and other men who have sex with men in Europe and Canada, and another trial of the microbicide 1% vaginal tenofovir gel in South African women. There will also be data from a PrEP “demonstration project” that provided the strategy in a real-life context for Kenyan and Ugandan couples with one HIV-positive and one HIV-negative partner.
We don’t know what the specific headlines will be, but we can say with confidence that one take-away must be this: The future of HIV prevention is on the line.

In our latest report, AVAC Report 2014/15: Prevention on the Line, we provide a clear agenda for what needs to happen, what’s missing, and why it matters now more than ever before.

Specifically, we argue that:

  • Ambitious prevention goals matter. They can galvanize new action, in part by expanding our sense of what’s possible.
  • But these goals will only work if they’re feasible, well-defined, measurable, and backed by adequate resources and political support. The prevention goals issued so far are inspiring but they don’t yet meet those requirements.
  • As the UNAIDS “Fast Track” for 2020 set aspirational goals, clear short-term targets are also urgently needed. We can’t wait for five years to see if the world is on track to end the AIDS epidemic.
  • The global AIDS response is running at a major financial deficit. New targets will not be met—and may even be irrelevant—if we fail to close a growing global funding gap.

Recent breakthroughs in HIV research have transformed the ability to curb new infections, making it possible to contemplate the end of the global AIDS epidemic. But prevention could be left behind if global leadership fails to make it a priority.

Recently, UNAIDS issued broad goals for HIV testing, ART provision and virologic suppression over the next five years. According to the agency, achieving these “90-90-90” goals would put the world on track to effectively end the AIDS epidemic by 2030.

On the prevention front, UNAIDS seeks to reduce new infections worldwide from 2.1 million in 2013 to 500,000 in 2020, and to eliminate stigma and discrimination. These are ambitious goals and worth aspiring to. But something important is missing from the picture—intervention-specific targets with the specificity, strategy and resources to match. The goal is great. What’s missing is how to get there.

In twenty years, we will have ample hindsight as to whether today’s targets mattered in the quest to end AIDS.

But right now, foresight and focus are urgently required. We’re concerned about whether the targets that have been set are the right ones, how much targets matter—particularly in the context of a global response running at a disastrous funding deficit—and where prevention targets other than those focused on the antiretrovirals in HIV-positive individuals—fit in. We’re also cognizant that targets can turn from audacious to absurd in the blink of an eye if financing, political will and community buy-in are missing.

AVAC works in coalitions in many of the countries hardest hit by the epidemic. Targets that are developed Geneva, Washington DC and other corridors of power can bear little resemblance to the realities of AIDS endemic countries and communities. Where there’s no reality, there’s no relevance. It’s essential that countries have the technical and financial resources to make global targets relevant to national context. Otherwise, the loftiest goals will be ignored.

As we argue in this Report, targets have played a critical role in changing the course of the epidemic. Likewise, a poorly-thought out target can have no impact at all. Right now, it’s critical that targets and tactics are matched to the lofty but achievable goal of bringing an end to AIDS. This is why we’ve devoted the first section of the Report to a look at why targets matter, what targets are missing, and how advocates for a comprehensive response need to work together to ensure smart, strategic targets across the spectrum of prevention options.

We also focus on issues that underpin (and, sometimes, undermine) the ability to meet these targets. We identify three specific areas for action:

  • Align high impact strategies with human rights and realities. Biomedical advances of the past eight years have made it scientifically plausible to talk about ending the epidemic. But plausible doesn’t mean possible. Today some scientists and public health professionals are focused on what can be achieved biomedically—without enough attention to the structural and social contexts in which treatment prevention are delivered. At the same time, some rights-focused partners speak of HIV as being exclusively pill-oriented, suggesting that there isn’t any dynamism or action on the rights-based fronts. It need not be a permanent rift—indeed it cannot be. If science does not get synched up with human rights then then there is little hope of bringing the epidemic to a conclusive end.
  • Invest in an oral PrEP-driven paradigm shift. The world is failing to deliver the most effective interventions with smart strategy and at scale. Daily oral PrEP for HIV prevention is just one example. Global targets for PrEP may be released in the coming months, but there aren’t any plans in place to meet them. Demonstration projects are small and disconnected, funding is limited and policy makers aren’t heeding the growing demand from men and women, including young women in Africa. Now is the time to spend and act to fill these gaps.
  • Demand short-term results on the path to long-term goals. It will be years before the world has an AIDS vaccine, cure strategies, long-acting injectable ARVs or multipurpose prevention technologies that reduce the risk of HIV acquisition and provide contraception. But there’s plenty of activity in clinical trials and basic science for these long-term goals. This activity needs to be aligned with short-term goals that can be used to measure progress and manage expectations.

As AVAC Report goes to press this week and as we prepare for CROI next week, the United States is grappling with profound questions about the ways that the lives of Black men and women are valued under the law. The world is trying to understand how the West African Ebola epidemics got out of control—and how to bring them to an end. And there is continued concern and vigilance over anti-homosexuality laws in Nigeria and the Gambia, and in hate-mongering environments and legislation that endanger LGBT individuals and many other marginalized groups around the world.

These events are not separate from the work that we do to fight AIDS. They embody the issues of racism, inequity, poverty and security that drive the epidemic that must be addressed to end it. In addition to the HIV-specific work laid out in these pages, it is essential to work towards fundamental, lasting and positive change in each of these areas. That will be history-making, indeed.

Press Release

With future of HIV prevention “on the line,” AVAC calls for sharper, bolder strategy to end the epidemic

Contacts

Mitchell Warren, mitchell@avac.org, +1-914-661-1536

Kay Marshall, kay@avac.org, +1-347-249-6375

New York — In a report issued today, AVAC warned that global HIV prevention efforts are in jeopardy due to an absence of strategic targets, resources and specific implementation plans to translate science, slogans and goals into action. The report calls for a robust set of global HIV prevention targets tailored to specific interventions and demands action in several key areas of the global AIDS response, including expanded rollout of daily oral pre-exposure prophylaxis, or PrEP, and alignment of science and human rights-based agendas.

“We’re at a make-or-break moment and the future of HIV prevention is on the line,” said Mitchell Warren, AVAC’s executive director. “Advances in HIV treatment and prevention research have made it possible to contemplate ending the AIDS epidemic in our lifetimes, but that will only happen with smarter planning, increased resources and greater accountability.”

The report was released ahead of the Conference on Retroviruses and Opportunistic Infections (CROI) in Seattle (Feb. 23-26), where researchers are expected to present data from several major HIV prevention trials, including studies that could help drive global implementation of PrEP, as well as a key study of a tenofovir-based vaginal gel for women.

Report calls for smart, realistic goals and targets for HIV prevention

Today’s report, entitled Prevention on the Line, takes a close look at global goals for HIV prevention and what it will take to make them a reality. UNAIDS recently adopted the broad goals of reducing new HIV infections worldwide from 2.1 million in 2013 to 500,000 and eliminating stigma and discrimination, both by the year 2020.

Drawing upon lessons from WHO’s “3 x 5” HIV treatment initiative and other case studies, the AVAC Report concludes that ambitious prevention goals are critical – but that they will only work if they’re feasible, well-defined, measurable and supported with adequate resources and political commitment. In the case of the new UNAIDS prevention goals, the report points to a critical need for more specific, interim targets that can be tracked between now and 2020; for better data and monitoring approaches; and for resource allocations that are directly tied to achieving those targets.

“The UNAIDS prevention goals for 2020 are ambitious and inspiring,” said Warren. “But something important is missing from this picture: how to get there. We need a clear path forward, including short-term targets, so we don’t wait five years to see if the world is on track. And new targets won’t be met – and may even be irrelevant – if we fail to close the growing global funding gap for HIV prevention.”

Bold action needed to advance AVAC’s agenda to end AIDS

The report also recommends key actions to advance AVAC’s three-part agenda to end AIDS. First issued in 2011, the agenda calls for sustained efforts to deliver proven prevention tools, demonstrate and roll out new options such as PrEP and develop long-term solutions such as long-acting ARV-based prevention, vaccines and cure strategies.

Key recommendations for 2015 include:

1. Align high-impact HIV prevention with human rights and realities. Research has demonstrated the potential of high-impact prevention strategies, including biomedical approaches like HIV treatment for people living with HIV and voluntary medical male circumcision (VMMC). But these strategies won’t succeed in the real world if we give short shrift to human rights concerns, or if we fail to involve affected communities in designing and implementing prevention programs. Recent experience with treatment and VMMC, in particular, has shown that community buy-in is an essential ingredient of successful rollout and scale-up.

2. Invest now to scale up access to PrEP. Landmark trials have shown that daily oral PrEP is a powerful HIV prevention tool, and studies at next week’s CROI meeting could provide additional support. But the pace of rollout remains far too slow. Demonstration projects are small and disconnected, funding is limited and policy makers are not yet heeding growing demands for access. Funders should invest now in large-scale targeted implementation of PrEP, linked to national programs. National regulatory authorities and health ministries should prioritize licensure and rollout.

3. Accelerate research into long-term solutions. We must sustain and accelerate research on solutions such as an effective AIDS vaccine, long-acting antiretroviral prevention and treatment and a cure. Just like the rest of the AIDS response, this research needs its own short-term targets, aligned to long-term goals.

The new report and related resources, including downloadable graphics, are available now at www.avac.org/report2014-15.

###

About AVAC: Founded in 1995, AVAC is a non-profit organization that uses education, policy analysis, advocacy and a network of global collaborations to accelerate the ethical development and global delivery of AIDS vaccines, male circumcision, microbicides, PrEP and other emerging HIV prevention options as part of a comprehensive response to the pandemic.

US CDC Says to Counsel Men About the Cut

Earlier this week, the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) released draft recommendations on male circumcision, stating that men of all ages (and parents of male minors) should be counseled on the health benefits of voluntary medical male circumcision. The recommendations do not call for universal male circumcision but recognize its power to prevent sexually transmitted infections and suggest a discussion about male circumcision with providers:

These recommendations are intended to assist health care providers in the United States who are counseling men and parents of male infants in decision making about male circumcision conducted by health care providers (i.e. medically performed) as it relates to the prevention of human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) infection, sexually transmitted infections (STIs), and other health outcomes. Such decision making is made in the context of not only health considerations, but also other social, cultural, ethical, and religious factors.  

The document—Recommendations for Providers Counseling Male Patients and Parents Regarding Male Circumcision and the Prevention of HIV Infection, STIs, and other Health Outcomes—reflects the data that show in heterosexual men that medical male circumcision can reduce risk of HIV infection by around 60 percent and reduce risk of other sexually transmitted infections such as HPV and herpes.  These data are the basis for voluntary adult male circumcision programs implemented as a primary strategy to prevent HIV in 14 priority countries in East and Southern Africa, where HIV rates are high and circumcision rates are low. 

Acknowledging the different epidemics between the US and countries in Africa, the CDC notes that some subpopulations in the US where HIV continues to rage could benefit from male circumcision—in particular heterosexual men at higher risk including African-American and Hispanic men, traditionally living in communities with higher rates of HIV and lower rates of male circumcision. 

There are little data on male circumcision’s effect on risk reduction in gay men and other men who have sex with men whose risk for HIV exposure is primarily via anal sex, although there is a biological rationale for a potential protective effect for the insertive partner (or “top”) in anal sex. But data on effect are not available. 

The draft recommendations are open for public comment for 45 days, closing on January 16, 2015. Visit the online comment portal here.

In 2012, the American Academy of Pediatrics updated its position on male circumcision noting that the benefits of newborn male circumcision outweigh the risks and that those families interested should have access to it. 

For more on medical male circumcision, visit AVAC’s webpage on the topic. 

UNAIDS Report has Bold Vision, Key Messages—But Needs More Precision on HIV Prevention

UNAIDS recently released Fast Track: Ending the AIDS Epidemic by 2030, its report for World AIDS Day (December 1, 2014). Coming nearly two weeks early, the launch was, itself, fast-tracked—and there’s plenty of “we can’t wait” urgency within the pages of the report, starting with the first page (that does more, typographically, with red ribbons than you might believe is possible). It reads:

“We have bent the trajectory of the AIDS epidemic. Now we have five years to break the epidemic or we risk the epidemic springing back even stronger.”

This is on target and a message to convey urgently and with clarity. UNAIDS has its work cut out as an agency that can provide leadership, mobilize resources and push for the shift to community-based service delivery that emerges as one of the core recommendations in the report.

In broad strokes, it’s the right message, with the right vision, at the right time.

But an effective response depends on strategy, details, milestones, resources and specifics—and these are still lacking. This is to be expected, as the UNAIDS Prevention and Non-Discrimination Targets are still in draft form.

The Fast Track World AIDS Day report is clear on what needs to happen to achieve the “90-90-90” goal that calls for 90 percent of people living with HIV to know their status, 90 percent of those to be on antiretroviral therapy (ART) and 90 percent of those to be virologically suppressed by 2020.

It also suggests the components of prevention programming that should also come on line—listing, in various places, male and female condoms, voluntary medical male circumcision, oral pre-exposure prophylaxis (PrEP) for sex workers, men who have sex with men, serodiscordant couples and adolescents, as well as cash transfers for young girls, harm reduction, structural interventions, mass media and behavior change. These prevention elements appear in different subsets throughout the document, leaving some confusion about what, exactly, is essential.

Everything that the UNAIDS report lists is important. But the details of what goes where—which packages, in which places—and what specific terms mean are missing. Cash transfers, for example, can be delivered in a range of ways, with different objectives and different outcomes.

There are also some elements that receive considerably less emphasis. Research and development of more potent ARVs for treatment and prevention, new prevention options for women and other key populations, vaccine and cure strategies, are fundamental to long-term success in “breaking the epidemic”. Within the five-year timeframe set by UNAIDS, there are short-term milestones to set and achieve in each of these areas, even though the ultimate goals may not be reached for many years.

The good news is that this is a solvable problem. We as advocates and activists must use our impatience and collective wisdom to fast-track a process to ensure that clear targets, resources and messages are developed with the same strategy, rigor and urgency as 90-90-90.

AVAC is working with many of our partners to inform this process. This new report adds urgency to this task and clarity to the questions we need to address. As the report stresses, we must all “hold one another accountable for results and make sure no one is left behind.”

In the coming days, AVAC will release “Prevention on the Line”—a briefing paper with core recommendations for effective target-setting across the research-to-rollout continuum. This will summarize core messages and analysis that will be expanded in AVAC Report 2014/15. To receive the Report and other updates in your inbox, please join our Advocates’ Network. Stay tuned—and stay in touch.

Click here to download the new UNAIDS report.

If It Works, We Should Use It

This was originally published on the What’sUpHIV blog that provided live coverage during HIV R4P 2014.

While numbers and slogans are important in themselves, focus should also be given to interventions that are making positive impact,” that’s how Mitchell Warren, Executive Director of AVAC, opened the 2014 HIV R4P Advocates’ Pre-Conference Workshop.

In his talk, titled, HIV Prevention: Research, reality & context, Warren observed that, “method mix is needed by the community members and not the policy maker.” And so it is critical for civil society to push for access to the full range of biomedical interventions which research has proven efficacious, like PrEP (Pre-exposure prophylaxis) and VMMC (voluntary medical male circumcision). Such interventions have to be embraced by policy makers in Africa, if the quest to end the AIDS epidemic by 2030 is going to be achieved.

Warren summed up by saying that, “It is therefore incumbent upon us to ensure that all our efforts are aimed at rolling out interventions that would save more people from contracting HIV in our communities.” I couldn’t agree more.